fintech

Why Bitcoin buyers get different prices on African exchanges

A Bitcoin buyer in South Africa could pay a different price depending on which exchange they use. The gap is not always about the value of Bitcoin itself. Trading volumes, currency conversion and transaction fees all affect the final bill.

Crypto

Crypto

Share
AI analysisGenerated by Business Tech Africa AI

Check the price of Bitcoin on three cryptocurrency exchanges and there is a good chance you will find three different figures. For someone buying with rand, the difference raises a practical question: why does the same Bitcoin cost more on one platform than another?

SentimentNeutralDepthModerateRead time3 min

AI-generated summary. It can miss nuance — read the full story above for the complete picture.

Check the price of Bitcoin on three cryptocurrency exchanges and there is a good chance you will find three different figures. For someone buying with rand, the difference raises a practical question: why does the same Bitcoin cost more on one platform than another?

Advertisement

Part of the answer lies in how exchanges operate. They do not all have the same customers, trading volumes or supply of Bitcoin available at a particular time. On a busy exchange, buyers and sellers may be trading close to the prevailing market price. On a smaller platform, fewer available offers can push the buying price higher.

The rand changes the calculation

"Two exchanges can quote different Bitcoin prices, but the cheapest quote may not leave the buyer with the most Bitcoin."

South African buyers also have to account for currency conversion. Bitcoin is traded internationally, with the US dollar serving as a major pricing reference. Local exchanges must account for the rand-dollar exchange rate when displaying prices in rand. The rate used by one platform may differ from another. Some may also include a margin in their conversion process. This means two exchanges can show different rand prices even when international Bitcoin prices have barely moved.

The price is not the full cost

Trading fees are another part of the calculation that buyers can easily overlook. Take a person with R5,000 to spend. One exchange might show a lower Bitcoin price but charge more to process the transaction. Another might quote a higher price but have lower trading costs. There are also differences between buying and selling prices. On an order-book exchange, the available offers determine what a customer can buy or sell for. An instant buy service may provide a fixed quote that includes a spread. Deposit and withdrawal charges add to the cost, particularly for people moving money between banks and cryptocurrency platforms.

Put three exchanges to the test

Advertisement

A comparison using actual transactions would show how much these differences matter. Take three exchanges available to South African customers and check their prices at the same time. Use R5,000 as the purchase amount and record the Bitcoin price, trading fee, spread, deposit charge and withdrawal cost.

The important figure is how much Bitcoin each platform delivers after fees, not simply the price displayed on its homepage. The exercise should also include the selling side. If the buyer decides to sell the Bitcoin, how much rand would each platform pay after its charges? That gives a more useful picture of what it costs to enter and exit a trade.

Why traders cannot simply pocket the difference

Price differences between exchanges sometimes attract attention from people looking for arbitrage opportunities. The idea is to buy Bitcoin where it is cheaper and sell it where the price is higher. In practice, the calculation is less straightforward. Bitcoin has to be transferred between platforms, and that takes time. During the transfer, prices can change. Withdrawal fees, network charges and platform limits can also reduce the margin. A price difference that looked attractive when the trade started may no longer exist by the time the Bitcoin arrives. For smaller transactions, the costs can outweigh the potential return.

What buyers should compare

For someone in South Africa buying Bitcoin, the exchange with the lowest advertised price is not necessarily the one offering the best deal. The more useful comparison is the amount of Bitcoin received for the money spent, followed by what it would cost to sell and withdraw the proceeds. That is where the real difference between exchanges becomes clear.

Reporting for Business Tech Africa on the funding, tools and strategy shaping the continent's founders and SMEs.

Was this useful?0 reactions
Crypto
Read nextenergy

Bitcoin Mining in South Africa: The Electricity Bill Is Only the Start

Eskom’s proposed R1.20 electricity tariff sounds attractive, but one mining machine could take years to pay for itself.

Vutomi Manzini · readContinue reading