Business School

Business School - The Family-Business Operating Code

Week 9 of a 12-week exclusive Business Lesson series intended for African Startup businesses. This week we take a look at the tricky family run businesses and what should be in place to prevent family discord and business disruptions.

Business School

Business School

Share

BUSINESS SCHOOL  ·  OPERATOR LESSONS  ·  WEEK 9 OF 12

Advertisement

Start here if relatives are on the payroll, in the share register, or both.

In many African businesses, the first people on the books are family. A brother helps with deliveries. A cousin keeps the accounts. A parent or relative invests money at the start. That works while everyone is still building. It stops working the month the firm is large enough that someone must decide who gets paid what, who can hire, and who can sign for a load. The argument is rarely about the work. It is about four things that were never written down separately: who owns the firm, who has a job, what that job is paid, and who has a voice when decisions are made.

Ownership, a job, a salary and a voice in the business operation are four different things. Mixing them turns every pay discussion into an ownership discussion and every ownership discussion into a family argument.

Our CleanLine Example Continues

CleanLine is a made-up packing firm used  for illustration purpose in these lessons so the numbers stay concrete. It sells 5-litre drums of cleaning concentrate to workshops and small regional chains. The lowest price it will accept per drum is 165.00. That price covers the concentrate, the bottle, the cap, the label, the delivery, the cost of waiting for payment, and returns for leaks or short deliveries. The founder’s younger brother has driven the bakkie and handled collections for three years. He is paid 18,000 a month. He is not on the share register. Their mother put in 120,000 at the start and receives a monthly transfer of 8,000 that no one calls a dividend or a loan. No one has written down who decides on a new hire or a price change.

A worked example: CleanLine writes the four things on one page

Last month the brother asked for a raise to R25,000 and a seat at the weekly stock meeting. The founder said the firm could not afford it. The brother pointed to the mother’ s monthly transfer and asked why that continued while his pay stayed the same. The accounts person, who is not family, stopped answering WhatsApp messages after 5 pm. Two workshops delayed orders because no one would confirm the next load. The argument cost a week of quiet operations and one lost re-order worth about R14,000 in contribution.

Advertisement

The founder and the brother sat down with a one-page note. It listed four lines. Ownership: the founder holds 100% of the shares; the mother’ s 120,000 is recorded as a loan that the firm repays at 8,000 a month until it is cleared, with no interest. Job: the brother is the delivery and collections lead. Pay: market rate for that role in the area is 20,000; he receives 18,000 with a written note that the difference is because he also receives a company bakkie for personal use on weekends. Voice: he decides the daily route and which overdue accounts to call; he does not decide new hires, the floor price, or which supplier to use. They both signed the page. The accounts person was shown the page the next morning. The following week the stock meeting ran on time and the delayed workshop re-ordered.

Three family realities this market will not negotiate away

•      Ownership, a job, a salary and a voice in the business operation are four different things. Mixing them turns every pay discussion into an ownership discussion and every ownership discussion into a family argument.

•      A relative on the payroll is still an employee. The firm can only pay what the work produces after the floor price is set and the costs deducted. Paying more because someone is family is a decision that must be written down with a reason, not assumed.

•      A non-family manager cannot work if every decision still needs a family meeting. The person must know, in writing, which decisions they can make alone and which ones still need the founder.

Five steps you can run this week

1. Write the four lines for every relative who is paid or who put in money

Name, ownership share or loan amount, job title and what the job actually does, monthly pay, and which decisions that person can make alone. Use one page. Do not write a long agreement. If the person is not family, the same page still works.

2. Set the pay rule in plain language

Look up what a similar role pays in your town or city for someone who is not related to you. Pay that rate, or write the difference and the reason on the same page. Reasons that are usable: company vehicle for personal use, housing, or a lower rate because the person also receives a share of profit. Reasons that are not usable: because he is my brother, or because mother expects it.

3. Name the decisions the non-family person can make

If you have already hired or plan to hire someone who is not family for accounts, sales or operations, write the three decisions they can make without calling you. Write the three decisions that still need you. Show them the page. This is the same idea as the one-page terms sheet used with customers: the rule is on paper before the argument starts.

4. Record any family money as a loan or as shares, not as a monthly transfer with no name

If a parent or relative put in money and receives a monthly amount, write whether that amount is a loan repayment, a salary, or a share of profit. Put the balance left on the same page. A transfer with no name becomes an argument the month cash is tight.

5. Talk about who runs the firm next year, not in twenty years

Succession is an operating question for this year if the founder is the only person who can quote, approve a load, or open the bank. Name one person who can do each of those three things if the founder is away for two weeks. Write the name next to the task. That is the start. An estate plan can wait.

What to measure next month

Number of relatives on the payroll who have the four lines written and signed. Target: all of them.

Whether any monthly transfer to a family member still has no name (loan, salary or profit share). Target: zero.

Whether the non-family person, if you have one, has made at least one decision from the list without calling the founder. Target: yes.

The mistake that looks like progress

Raising a relative’s pay to stop the argument, then still having no page that separates ownership from the job. The quiet lasts until the next tight cash-flow month. Or hiring a non-family manager and then reversing every decision they make because the family has not agreed what that person can decide. Both leave the firm running on mood instead of a written code.

If you only do one thing

Tonight, take the relative who is paid the most or who receives the largest monthly transfer. Write the four lines on one page: ownership or loan, job, pay and reason, and the decisions they can make alone. Ask them to read it. Do not ask them to sign yet if the conversation is still raw. The page is the start.

Next Tuesday: the operating gaps that never make the pitch deck — the numbers and habits that are missing when a founder tries to raise money or sell the firm.

Reporting for Business Tech Africa on the funding, tools and strategy shaping the continent's founders and SMEs.

Was this useful?0 reactions
Business School
Read nextBusiness School

Business School - Stock-outs, Overstock and Ports: Inventory Rules When Supply Is Unreliable

This week we take a look at how businesses can better manage their Stock - Lesson 8 of our Business School Series on startup business leadership lessons

Greg Stewart · readContinue reading