Business School

The Influence Edge - An Ad Agency and a PR Agency Walk Into a Brief

The Influence Edge

The Influence Edge

Share

A lesser-known fact about me: I write commercial treatments for film directors. I’ve been fortunate enough to work on campaigns featuring David Beckham, Morgan Freeman and Simone Biles, from Pepsi to Nintendo to Universal Studios. I love the visual and written creativity this demands of me.

Advertisement

I’ve spent thousands of hours over the past decade, deciding on what makes a TV commercial land: the idea, the execution, the storytelling, the emotional connection with the audience and, above all, what it needs to achieve for the brand.

Although much of my career has been spent in communications and reputation management, it never exclusively ends there. Brand strategy runs through all of it, as does working in lockstep with partner agencies on sentiment, messaging and reach.

Break down the silos. Advertising, experiential, PR and social need to be in the room when the first brief is given, working from the same deck. And put the community front and centre.

Where Brand Supports Marketing Strategy

A treatment is where a commercial idea is first tested on paper. It has to sell the director’s vision to the agency and the client. The strongest ones answer a second question, too: where does this idea go once the shoot is over?

So when I look at a TV commercial or brand campaign, I’m already asking what else it could do. How does it serve the wider marketing strategy? Is there a PR story in the idea? An experiential idea? A way to turn 30 or 60 seconds of advertising into a much bigger brand conversation?

And here’s what sometimes gets overlooked: a campaign is treated as the finished product when it should be the starting point.

Advertisement

The advertising and PR industries have both changed - agencies are not answering briefs with a single campaign solution. Exceptional creative is no longer enough on its own, and neither is a headline-grabbing activation campaign for PR reach. The best ideas have to travel across disciplines and audiences.

Intersection of Marketing Disciplines

Let’s stick with TVCs for a moment. The commercial is made, the media plan is executed and the campaign is considered done. But we’re no longer operating in a marketing economy where we can afford to work in silos. PR, social and experiential cannot be afterthoughts. Those days are over.

The case for this has never been stronger. We’re overloaded and overserved with media content on every available platform. If you want your brand to be experienced, wherever your audience encounters it, the thinking behind it needs to have a strategy without borders.

An indulgent fact I’d like to share (I’m a history geek): in 1545, the Swiss polymath scholar Conrad Gesner was already complaining of a “confusing and harmful abundance of books”. Overload isn’t new. The scale is. Ideas get diluted the moment they compete for the same attention. A single commercial, however well crafted, is one voice in a very loud room.

Reach Across The Line

Consider what a commercial with impact already contains. Somewhere in those 60 seconds is a line people will quote and a moment where they see themselves in the story. Cut them out and you have the raw material for a social campaign. But it goes beyond reach. Reach is what you get when you repeat the same creative in more places. Strategy is recognising what other rooms that reach can inhabit.

It works in reverse, too. An experiential campaign with strategic spine and creative nerve can become the commercial. The experience people queued for, filmed and repurposed for their own platforms becomes the 30 seconds that reaches everyone who wasn’t there. The idea doesn’t have to start on a screen to end up there.

Avoid Strategy Silo's

Marketers love the word funnel. I hate it, because it paints an impossibly tidy picture, with audiences lining up neatly through the touchpoints. They don’t behave that way. People arrive from the commercial, the headline, the experiential campaign or a social post in a far messier order. What matters is that each encounter feels connected to the same idea, expressed in a way that makes sense for that channel.

That only works if the people making it aren’t working in silos. Advertising cannot operate in an advertising silo and PR in a communications one.

It also means being comfortable with friction. PR will step on advertising’s toes, and advertising will fight back. Good. That argument held early is far cheaper than the one held after launch. Some of the best work comes out of that tension.

It means agreeing on success, too. If advertising chases awareness and PR chases coverage, the campaign pulls in two directions. One brief and one shared outcome keep it moving in one direction.

Reductive, I know, but I’m giving you an example, not crafting an award-winning creative conceptual marketing campaign. Picture a new online fashion retailer. The conventional approach might be a sexy, cinematic and polished TVC showcasing the collection, supported by a hefty media spend.

But what if the TVC was the fashion show itself?

Imagine a live fashion event built around the brand’s values and the community it wants to bring together. The runway show is filmed as the commercial, with product shots and brand storytelling woven into the creative. But the event is bigger than the commercial. It’s a gathering of people who share an interest in fashion, design and the creative thinking behind the clothes.

Invite the fashion community into the room, alongside journalists. Let the journalists interview the designers, speak to the people behind the collection and engage with the community itself. Give them stories to take beyond the event, rather than simply asking them to cover a launch.

Stories Travel Across Networks

The community is part of the experience, not just an audience. People photograph and film the runway, the designers, the clothes and the moments that resonate with them. They share those moments with their own followers, who see familiar faces and a community they recognise. The brand’s story travels through networks of people who already have something in common, creating an expanding pool of reach and participation. We’re in the authenticity era of TVCs. It doesn’t get more real than this.

The event is simultaneously the TVC, an experiential campaign, a PR opportunity and a source of social content. Each discipline has a role. This isn’t a commercial with a few extra channels attached. It’s a brand experience conceived to live across all of them.

Same idea, different doors. And the audience walks in through whichever one is closest.

Break down the silos. Advertising, experiential, PR and social need to be in the room when the first brief is given, working from the same deck. And put the community front and centre. 

The ideas that travel furthest treat audiences as communities, not targets. Communities don’t share ads. They share values. When people see themselves in a brand’s story, they help keep it alive. That’s how a campaign keeps getting oxygen long after the agencies have delivered their final reports and closed their Macs.


Sam Swaine is the founder of Audibly, a boutique, end-to-end podcast partner for founders, executives and brands who want their voice to operate strategically. Sam advises business leaders and organisations on executive communications, strategic positioning, reputation architecture and growth strategy, helping ambitious businesses align what they say with where they're going.

Reporting for Business Tech Africa on the funding, tools and strategy shaping the continent's founders and SMEs.

Was this useful?0 reactions
The Influence Edge
Read nextBusiness School

The Influence Edge - The Horse Has Bolted: Anatomy of a Crisis Statement Gone Catastrophically Wrong

This Week Sam Swaine dives into the murky waters of responses to major public reveals and lessons on what not to do in a communications crises situation.

Sam Swaine · readContinue reading